Fix random proposals order in the same session

Using `setseed` and ordering by `RAND()` doesn't always return the same
results because, although the generated random numbers will always be
the same, PostgreSQL doesn't guarantee the order of the rows it will
apply those random numbers to, similar to the way it doesn't guarantee
an order when the `ORDER BY` clause isn't specified.

Using something like `reorder("legislation_proposals.id % #{seed}")`,
like we do in budget investments, is certainly more elegant but it makes
the test checking two users get different results fail sometimes, so
that approach might need some adjustments in order to make the results
more random.
This commit is contained in:
Javi Martín
2018-12-19 16:43:19 +01:00
parent 70a1b7d1ff
commit 660c59016b
2 changed files with 19 additions and 7 deletions

View File

@@ -103,7 +103,12 @@ class Legislation::ProcessesController < Legislation::BaseController
@proposals = @proposals.search(params[:search]) if params[:search].present? @proposals = @proposals.search(params[:search]) if params[:search].present?
@current_filter = "winners" if params[:filter].blank? && @proposals.winners.any? @current_filter = "winners" if params[:filter].blank? && @proposals.winners.any?
@proposals = @proposals.send(@current_filter).page(params[:page])
if @current_filter == "random"
@proposals = @proposals.send(@current_filter, session[:random_seed]).page(params[:page])
else
@proposals = @proposals.send(@current_filter).page(params[:page])
end
if @process.proposals_phase.started? || (current_user && current_user.administrator?) if @process.proposals_phase.started? || (current_user && current_user.administrator?)
legislation_proposal_votes(@proposals) legislation_proposal_votes(@proposals)
@@ -125,12 +130,9 @@ class Legislation::ProcessesController < Legislation::BaseController
end end
def set_random_seed def set_random_seed
seed = (params[:random_seed] || session[:random_seed] || rand).to_f seed = (params[:random_seed] || session[:random_seed] || rand(10_000_000)).to_i
seed = (-1..1).cover?(seed) ? seed : 1
session[:random_seed] = seed session[:random_seed] = seed
params[:random_seed] = seed params[:random_seed] = seed
::Legislation::Proposal.connection.execute "select setseed(#{seed})"
end end
end end

View File

@@ -48,13 +48,23 @@ class Legislation::Proposal < ActiveRecord::Base
scope :sort_by_title, -> { reorder(title: :asc) } scope :sort_by_title, -> { reorder(title: :asc) }
scope :sort_by_id, -> { reorder(id: :asc) } scope :sort_by_id, -> { reorder(id: :asc) }
scope :sort_by_supports, -> { reorder(cached_votes_score: :desc) } scope :sort_by_supports, -> { reorder(cached_votes_score: :desc) }
scope :sort_by_random, -> { reorder("RANDOM()") }
scope :sort_by_flags, -> { order(flags_count: :desc, updated_at: :desc) } scope :sort_by_flags, -> { order(flags_count: :desc, updated_at: :desc) }
scope :last_week, -> { where("proposals.created_at >= ?", 7.days.ago)} scope :last_week, -> { where("proposals.created_at >= ?", 7.days.ago)}
scope :selected, -> { where(selected: true) } scope :selected, -> { where(selected: true) }
scope :random, -> { sort_by_random } scope :random, -> (seed) { sort_by_random(seed) }
scope :winners, -> { selected.sort_by_confidence_score } scope :winners, -> { selected.sort_by_confidence_score }
def self.sort_by_random(seed)
ids = pluck(:id).shuffle(random: Random.new(seed))
return all if ids.empty?
ids_with_order = ids.map.with_index { |id, order| "(#{id}, #{order})" }.join(", ")
joins("LEFT JOIN (VALUES #{ids_with_order}) AS ids(id, ordering) ON #{table_name}.id = ids.id")
.order("ids.ordering")
end
def to_param def to_param
"#{id}-#{title}".parameterize "#{id}-#{title}".parameterize
end end